David Cook is Your American Idol Comments (Page 2)

15 Comments

11. Colleen Says:
    May 22nd, 2008 8:14 AM
    

    I am absolutely releived and thrilled that David Cook won. Both talented but Cook will last where as Archuletta may have faded out. Can wait to see him live in concert

12. Anon Suomy Says:
    May 23rd, 2008 3:08 AM
    

    Through out the whole season, the top two were obvious choices. Due to their immense talent and great voice. Through out every performance except the finals, i thought DC was a sure win. However, his last performance didn't quite show how talented he really is. He didn't quite produce that winning song. In fact i think his winning song was rather MJ's and Mariah's. Based on the last performance, he didn't quite bring his game on. It was a disappointment, that last show, to come from an Idol Winner!
    
    David Archuleta really gave DC a run for his money and i'm sure he'll have a brilliant future ahead of him. Young talent with a great voice.
    
    Again, this is based on personal preferences.

13. Breanna Says:
    May 23rd, 2008 11:12 AM
    

    DAVID A. SHOULD HAVE WON!!!! HE WAS BETTER THEN DAVID C.!!!!!!!!!!!!

14. lindar Says:
    June 13th, 2008 7:07 PM
    

    Although this was a competition where only one person would be declared the winner, the truth is both David's were wonderful, unique and deserving. Since their styles were totally different, it doesn't make sense to say one is better than the other. It's really which kind of music do you prefer to listen to. I like them both, but I cannot stop playing David C.'s songs and find him very appealing.
    
    I am saying this because I don't understand so many people declaring the David they like as the only one who was any good. That's ridiculous. They were both great!
    
    To me, David Cook is the very best that AI has come up with in all the seasons.

15. Annie Says:
    June 23rd, 2008 7:58 PM
    

    IMHO, DC is the better musician and the better performer. But David A is the better singer and an amazing artist. Personally, I think both will soar for a very long time to come because they each to very different audiences.
    
    I had actually lost interest is AI over the years...until this finale. My David didn't win, and I was pretty bummed at first, but then DC won me over by the way he treated Archie after he won. (Not to his singing – I have a hard time listening to him because he misses his notes a lot – but to his humanity and kindness…it’s that different taste thing.) He is such a good guy and so is David A. I am proud of them both and so anxious to see them perform on tour!!!