American Idol Worship

American Idol Controversy: Topless Antonella Barba Pictures Surface Comments (Page 3)

186 Comments

« Previous
Next »
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
  1. LD Says:

    "Nice in person"from what I have read, but lacks serious class on T.V. - true colors showing through? GO LAKISHA!

  2. nice Says:

    the real controversy is she can't sing!! she shouldn't of made it over marissa!! the reason bailey forgot her words was because of her and her friend. she forgot the words during hollywood week!!

  3. Dave V. Says:

    i went to High school with Antonella.... man she is a hottie...especially in a catholic school girl uniform!

  4. charlie Says:

    i could've told you that italian jersey shore slut was no good. she sucks at singing too.

  5. Bob von Bob Says:

    The girl can't sing all that well but she is a real pleasure to look at and thus she should be voted for. Idol was never about talent anyway.

  6. Jackie Says:

    you know I don't see the big deal about the pics.. we are all guilty of doing something stupid.. no one is perfect... the thing I find funny is the fact people are cursing and name calling ...how old are we? especially the one that claims they don't want their children to see..blahblah... you are your own worst enemy..do you want your kid to speak disrespectfully like that?.. you all should be ashamed.. at least Antonella is following her dream.. and trying to do something with her life!.. and to the person who leaked these pics.. get over yourself and stop trying to ruin the poor girls chance.

  7. Phil Says:

    She's a college student guys and these pictures are obviously from a topless beach. RELAX. She took these before Idol and they leaked--big deal. If you have such a problem about your precious children seeing them then...*gasp*...DON'T LET YOUR KIDS SEE/VOTE FOR Ms. Barba.

    Seriously, the parents that complain are the parents that are too busy to do their jobs and PARENT their kids. The responsibility is yours, not hers.

  8. anonymous Says:

    this is to El Douche Nozzle

    First of all, ur kids are DEF gonna drink underage, as Im sure U did u punk... dont talk smack on Antonella...Im sure if u became famous there would def be some embaressing pics of you! and maybe even worse....DONT HATE cuz u want to be her...

  9. anonymous Says:

    this is too jrz Grl first of all Antonella is NOT a whore, u prob are! and that girl DID not sing better than them considering she DIDNT sing cuz she FORGOT the words! Antonella is hot and made it this far cuz she has a good voice, DEF better than urs....and even if U dont think she has a good voice, the judges did and thats ALL that mattered..right? PS u are a WHORE!!!! and suck major dick... LATA

  10. anonymous Says:

    Charlie u SUCKKKKKKKKKKKKK, jealous MOFO


  11. hv Says:

    1) jersey girls aren't haters 2) antonella cannot sing .. cmon lets be serious! & 3) she has no class. did u see her face after the judges told her she pretty much sucked on wed?! she could of at least smiled to the public and said "thanks anyways"..she was rude. and also on her first audition how she made her jersey friend look bad. i understand we all do crazy things but if there's a picture like that around then obviously it's goin to go AROUND..cleary she's needs to stop takin slutty ass pictures like that or jus keep them private. but i don't doubt her jersey friend was the one to post those pix up. i think bailey should of went through but oh well..

  12. jimmay Says:

    I am from Jerz. I am from really close to where she is from. Is the pic criminal? NO. Does she have a less than perfect voice? DEFinately. Is her attitude typical of a Jerz chick? ABSOFRIGGINLUTELY... love it or leave it... shes there, we are not. love it or leave it, she is a JerZ Shore GIRL.

  13. red~dog Says:

    The bottom line here is she sucked on opening night and needs to be booted off. Her and her rude ass friend ruined the chances of another and then lied to cover up there actions. Now that's a Jersey girl for ya huh?

  14. Albert Says:

    What the hell! Since when was this country run by the freakin Taliban! You morality nazi's should move to Pakistan so you can abstain from booze and beat women for showing their ankles in public.

    This hypocritical, double standard is what makes American women so psycho and is why the Europeans laugh at us.

    Antonella biggest problem is she is so beautiful she inspires hateful jealousy in the women who can't look like her and men who can't have her.

    Shame on all you haters.

  15. Justme Says:

    I don't think this girl should be in American Idol, do you guys know that kids also watch the show, and surf through the Idol website?
    And doesn't she have a little respect for her parents?
    Wanna have fun, fine, have some, but next time make sure YOU take the pictures, and YOU keep them in the privacy of your home..

  16. sunny Says:

    Pure and simple publicity stunt!!
    she got it!!
    now America is all over her, and she will probably win, cuz obviously people have eyes and looking at this pics, they all have became deaf..
    Smart publicity stunt!!

  17. hipporcitzzzzz Says:

    There are the so-called "racy" photos?????
    Are you kidding me? I have seen more exposed in a Victoria Secret Ad or in almost any hip hop video on TV. Someone is trying to make a quick buck. Looks like they are just funny pictures of friends. They need to start worrying more about the real perverts in the world than some innocent fun.

  18. hipporcitzzzzz Says:

    Oh and I also get a kick out of the parents who post on here and are totally convinced that their teenage kids would never do something like this EVER.

  19. Tony Soprano_Work in Waste Management Says:

    What 'da fuck is all 'dis whinin' about?? I see 'dis story a million times. So 'da girl is a rich spolied catholic school brat wit' no talent from jersey. So she poses on 'da toilet & with her top off on 'da beach wit' her rich friends. Can't yous just picture it? After she gets kicked off AI, it'll be catholic college durin 'da day, dancin at 'da Bing at night...

    Gotta talk to Sil about puttin in a fake toilet on 'da stage....

  20. Albert Says:

    You said it, T. Finally a real Italian with a grouded moral compass sticks up for his paisana Antonella.

    A toilet, though? Remember- Don't disrespect the Bing.

  21. spork Says:

    I'd hit it!

  22. The Legend Says:

    I love Jersey grils... and if you think these pics are bad.... you obviously lived a sheltered life... not a single one of these pics makes her skank or a slut... shes a young girl who is doing what young girls do... have a good time with your gf's, make bad decisions etc... you just hope that your experiences will only make you stronger.... which I'm sure this will...

    So everyone just relax... it's not like she is doing anything pornographic in these pics.. not to mention there wasn't a single picture of her naked with any guys....

    If she gets voted off, it should only be based on her singing ability... not because there are a few pg-13 pics on the internet....

    I hope to run into her and all her friends this summer.. they look like they are alot of fun....

    Dj'ais it is!!~!~~!

  23. Jo Jo Says:

    Most of us have done things in our lives we are not proud of. The sad part is that there are always opportunist out there ready to exploit one's error. However, throughout my life time, amazingly, I have seen people overcome those who have tried to destroy a career. An example who comes to mind was the detroned, first, African-American, Miss America, Vanessa Williams. Years later she is still going strong despite those tawdy published photos. It only goes to show that true talent grows stronger in the face of adversity.

  24. cindy Says:

    she seems very shy on camera and lost for words when Ryan asks her questions. No personality at all. Whats gotten her this far is her looks not her voice. She sucks.

  25. H Says:

    She might be good for a spin in the sack but not for much else.

« Previous
Next »
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Leave a Comment

You are posting as a guest. To post as a user, please Login or Register.

Name:

E-Mail:

Remember My Info

Your Comments
No need for HTML formatting, we insert line breaks. Allowed tags: <b> <i> <a>